When Family Members Disagree
A Practical Guide to Understanding What to do When Family Members Disagree About Funeral Arrangements.
Funeral arrangements can sometimes lead to disagreements between family members, particularly when people have different views about the wishes of the person who has died, the type of funeral or how much should be spent. These situations can be difficult to manage at an already stressful time. Establishing what is known about the deceased’s wishes, identifying who is responsible for the arrangements and keeping discussions focused on practical decisions may help family members reach an agreement.
​
For information about the broader complexities that can complicate funeral arrangements, please see our main guide linked below.
What Can Cause Disagreements?
Family members may disagree for several reasons, including:
​
-
Different interpretations of the deceased’s wishes
-
Differences over burial or cremation
-
Religious, cultural or personal preferences
-
The choice of funeral venue or service
-
The level of spending
-
Who should be involved in the funeral
-
Whether certain music, readings or tributes are appropriate
-
Disagreements about the burial location or existing family grave
​
Sometimes, disagreements arise because relatives have different relationships with the person who has died or have not had the opportunity to discuss funeral wishes before the death.
Whose Wishes Should Be Considered?
Where the deceased left written instructions or clearly expressed their wishes, these should be considered when making the arrangements. However, funeral instructions do not always cover every decision, and there may still be practical matters that need to be agreed.
​
If no clear wishes have been left, the person responsible for arranging the funeral will usually need to make decisions based on the information available and the circumstances. Where there is uncertainty about who has authority to make decisions, or a dispute cannot be resolved, independent legal advice may be appropriate.
​
For more information, please follow the link below to see our guide for what to do when there's no funeral plan.
How Can Family Members Work Towards an Agreement?
It may help to separate the decisions that need to be made from disagreements about how the funeral should be organised. Start by identifying what is already known about the deceased’s wishes and which decisions are most urgent.
​
It can also be useful to:
​
-
Agree who will act as the main point of contact.
-
Share relevant documents or information about the deceased’s wishes.
-
Give family members an opportunity to explain their views.
-
Focus on what would be appropriate for the person who has died.
-
Discuss the available options and their costs.
-
Avoid making assumptions about what other relatives want.
-
Ask the funeral director to explain any practical limitations.
​
Not every decision will necessarily satisfy everyone, but clear communication can help prevent misunderstandings and make it easier to agree on the arrangements.
How Clive Pugh Funeral Directors Can Help
If family members disagree about funeral arrangements, you do not have to manage the practical organisation on your own. Once you appoint Clive Pugh Funeral Directors, we can act as the main point of contact and help explain the choices that need to be made.
​
Depending on the circumstances, we can:
-
Discuss the available funeral options with the person responsible for the arrangements.
-
Explain the practical differences between burial and cremation.
-
Provide an estimate and clarify what the costs include.
-
Discuss the service, venue, coffin, transport and other arrangements.
-
Liaise with the chosen cemetery, churchyard, crematorium, minister or celebrant.
-
Explain which decisions need to be confirmed before arrangements can proceed.
-
​Keep you informed as the funeral arrangements are organised.
​
Our role is to provide clear information and coordinate the practical arrangements. We can help family members understand what is involved, but we cannot decide between relatives or resolve legal disputes on their behalf.
When Further Advice May Be Needed
If family members cannot agree about who should arrange the funeral, where the person should be buried or whether a particular arrangement can proceed, the situation may require advice beyond the funeral director’s role.
​
​Where there is a legal dispute, uncertainty about authority or disagreement concerning burial rights, you may need to seek independent legal advice. We can explain the practical funeral arrangements while you obtain any further guidance required.
If You Need Advice About Funeral Arrangements
If you are facing disagreements within your family, Clive Pugh Funeral Directors can provide straightforward advice about the arrangements and explain the options available.
​
You do not need to have every detail agreed before contacting us. We can discuss your circumstances, answer your questions and explain the next steps involved in arranging a funeral in Shrewsbury, Shropshire or the surrounding areas. Contact Clive Pugh Funeral Directors when you are ready.
With You Every Step of the Way
Date and Time
Following registration, a date and time can then be arranged.
Cremation or Burial
In many cases a loved one will have left their own specific preference. Once the decision for a cremation or burial has been made, a venue for the service and order of events can be agreed upon.
Chapel of Rest
Our private chapel is available for you to spend time with your loved one, also allowing your relatives and friends the chance to say "goodbye".
The Funeral Service
We will liaise with the Clergy, Humanist Minister or Celebrant of your choice. Alternatively, if no specific Minister is requested we can suggest a Minister who will guide you through the order of service. The readings, hymns and eulogies will all be discussed.
Coffins, Caskets and Urns
We offer a large range of traditional coffins, caskets and urns. You can choose from many different styles and we offer a range of price points. Should you want to offer a unique tribute to your loved one, ask us about our customisation options. If you are looking for something in particular, please let us know. We will make every effort to accommodate your needs.
Vehicles
We take pride in being able to offer a comprehensive selection of vehicles. A horse drawn hearse is also available upon request.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a funeral go ahead if family members do not agree?
This depends on the nature of the disagreement and who is responsible for making the arrangements. Some differences can be resolved through discussion, while disputes involving legal authority or burial rights may require independent advice before arrangements can proceed.
What if the deceased left instructions that some relatives disagree with?
Known wishes should be taken into account, even if some family members would have preferred a different arrangement. If the instructions are unclear or their legal status is disputed, further advice may be necessary.
Can a funeral director decide which family member is right?
No. A funeral director can explain the available options and coordinate arrangements with the person responsible for the funeral, but cannot determine the outcome of a family dispute or provide a legal ruling.
Who should be the main contact for the funeral director?
It is usually helpful for one person to act as the main point of contact, even if other family members are involved in decisions. This can reduce confusion and make it clearer who is confirming the arrangements.